Chicago's Property Tax Turmoil: Challenges After "Mansion Tax" Rejection

In a move that could significantly shape the direction of Chicago's future housing policies, voters resoundingly rejected Mayor Brandon Johnson’s proposal to impose a tax hike on real estate transactions exceeding $1 million. The “Mansion Tax” measure, aimed at channeling funds into combating homelessness and supporting affordable housing initiatives, faced opposition from just over half of the electorate, dealing a setback to the first-term Democrat’s progressive agenda.

Bloomberg referred to the rejection as a “blow” to 48-year-old Johnson.

Voters’ stance on this issue also highlights Johnson's problems in translating his campaign pledges into tangible policies. Elected on a platform advocating for increased contributions from the city’s wealthiest residents, Johnson’s ambitious “Bring Chicago Home” campaign largely relied on the passage of the “Mansion Tax” proposal. 

From the start, opponents cautioned that such a tax hike could exacerbate the city’s already delicate real estate market, while proponents argued it could generate $100 million annually.

“This is a city where we have already seen very large increases in taxes, very large increases in the cost of services because of policy decisions that have been made by the city government,” remarked John Hansen, a professor at the University of Chicago’s Department of Political Science, in Bloomberg’s piece.

For example, the Markellos family, who owns a 10-unit apartment building in Chicago, found themselves confronting a shocking 440% property tax increase last year. Michael Markellos, who co-owns the complex with his mother, found himself facing a $17,494 bill for a one-bedroom apartment for just one year. Markellos expressed frustration over the astronomical spike, emphasizing that his building is comprised of simple one-bedroom units intended for downtown workers and college graduates.

This recent property tax upheaval in Chicago echoes wider concerns about the area’s tax administration and assessment practices. The Cook County Assessor's Office, responsible for determining property values, faced scrutiny over its reclassification of apartments as residential properties, which reportedly led to the exorbitant tax increases faced by families like the Markelloses. 

Cook County residents also deal with significant delays in property tax refund payments, exacerbating financial strain and uncertainty, particularly for those on fixed incomes.

Chicago’s housing challenges have been further compounded by a burgeoning homelessness crisis, with over 68,000 individuals experiencing homelessness in 2021. In addition, an influx of more than 37,000 migrants to the city and its suburbs over the past year and a half has further strained resources and exacerbated housing shortages.

Before facing the electorate, Johnson’s proposal encountered legal obstacles, with real estate trade organizations filing a lawsuit alleging that the ballot language violated state statutes. The lack of specificity surrounding the proposed tax hike also drew criticism from fiscal watchdogs, including the Civic Federation, which voiced concerns about its potential impact on the city’s attractiveness and economic competitiveness on a national scale.

Meanwhile, in Los Angeles, the implementation of a similar “Mansion Tax” has yielded mixed results. Despite promises of generating substantial revenue for affordable housing projects, the tax fell short of expectations, collecting only $215 million in its inaugural year—well below the projected $600 million to $1.1 billion. Southern California news network ABC 7 notes that challenges like rising mortgage rates, construction costs, and preemptive property sales have hindered revenue generation, leading to intense scrutiny and potential electoral challenges.

As Chicago grapples with its housing crisis and tries to find a taxation policy that works, the fate of initiatives like the “Mansion Tax” showcases the difficult balance of addressing societal needs and maintaining economic stability. 

---